Trust and Pleasure
Eating is Intrinsically Emotional
This is the last but probably the most important theoretical concept in this blog. We’ve talked a lot about the physical, but we need to delve deeper into the emotional processes behind intuitive eating. Without learning more about trust and pleasure, we cannot move forward.
Every diet, every restriction, teaches you not to trust your body, not to trust food. You see yourself going from one extreme to another, losing control, feeling up and down. Your inability to achieve the goal of weight loss or weight maintenance leaves you feeling like a failure. But what has failed you is the dieting mentality and its lies, not your willpower. When you no longer listen to your body, you become more reliant on external sources to guide your eating: what’s available in front of you, levels of stress, marketing, etc. The more you are in tune with your body signals, the less vulnerable to “externally-directed” eating you become. Intuitive eating implies trust in your body, and this can be very difficult if you’ve lost it a long time ago. You may even think it’s impossible. But I’ve read about people who dieted up to the age of 60 and were finally able to reconnect with their hunger and satiety signals despite decades of mistrust. So I’m sure you can do it too.
So many people I talk to think that this method won’t work for them because they’re different, or too far gone, or too gluttonous. That’s just not true. The only people for whom Intuitive Eating doesn’t work are those who never really rekindle the trust with their body signals and never really let go of their restrictions. The ones who only give “pseudo-permission” to their body to become the leader of their eating behaviour, rather than unconditional permission. If you learn to give yourself this unconditional permission, you can learn to eat intuitively, lose weight (if you’re above your set-point) and find peace. Remember, we were all born intuitive eaters, it’s in our nature. There are no records of overweight wild animals because of all of them are intuitive eaters, as we are. They use instincts, never brains, to decide when to eat, what to eat, and how much.
Finally, we must also talk about pleasure, because food has been and always will be a hedonic activity. Pleasure is such an important part of life and eating, yet we often ignore it for the sake of weight loss and “nutrition”! Some people even feel that they don’t deserve to eat certain foods because they’re overweight. When eating is dissociated with pleasure, it becomes a chore - or even worse, a war. No peace can be found on a battleground. But satisfying your “psychological” hunger (in the sense of getting pleasure from your food) is as vital as satisfying your physical hunger. Eating carrots when you wanted chocolate will leave you feeling discontent and looking for something else. In the end, it will lead you to overeat. That’s why cravings and tastebuds are also important to listen to when you choose what you’re going to eat next. So strive to feel satisfied with what you eat, it will help prevent overeating!
On the road to becoming an intuitive eater, you will notice that every food item that you eat brings you a certain amount of pleasure that is finite, and same goes for the overall meal. Why does the first bite always taste better than the last? Let’s call it food saturation. There’s general food saturation and food-specific saturation. So every food item follows a decreasing curve, where the first bites are the best and the following bites are less and less satisfying. When you are aware of your senses and pay attention to your body signals, it’s pretty easy to tell when you’ve had enough of something (when you’ve reached food-specific saturation) and that soup or salad no longer provides any pleasure. That’s when it’s time to stop eating the food item, no matter how much is left in your plate, and move on to the next course, if you’ve not yet reached general saturation. Having variety in your plate obviously makes eating more enjoyable as there’s less of each food, so it takes longer to get tired of the general meal. This food-specific saturation phenomenon explains why we can be “full” for one food and still “hungry” for another. Contrary to what most people think, being unable to finish your main course but still having room for dessert is possible and even common. (No, it’s not just kid manipulation techniques!) Finally, it’s only when general saturation (satiation) is attained that the meal is over. You are no longer hungry for anything, and it’s time to stop eating. Again, this does not depend on what’s left in the plate, but only on your body signals. The feeling can be vague if you’ve ignored your signals for a long time, but one day it will be come very clear, as it is for intuitive eaters.
But what if “desire” comes in conflict with “satiety”? What if I still crave that chocolate even when I’m already full? It’s a complex issue. First, if you’re not yet an intuitive eater, the presence of cravings in the absence of hunger are probably residual symptoms of your restrictions. You’re still not giving yourself full permission to eat everything, you’re still hanging on to the belief that you must control what you eat, and that some unhealthy foods should be abstained from. In that case, you can’t fool your body: it will still think that calories are scarce, that it could starve tomorrow, that the food it wants might be taken away at anytime. It reacts by wanting to stock up in fear of future deprivation. Second, this could be a sign of emotional eating. Chocolate might be a comfort food - and even though your physical hunger has been quenched, your emotional needs are not fully met and you seek to appease yourself with food. But unfortunately, eating chocolate will not solve your emotional issues. It will probably even make it worse, because you will overeat and then feel ashamed of overeating, therefore increasing emotional distress. The only way out is to deal with the negative emotions that are leading you to eat without hunger in the first place, and instead turn to self-help, meditation, therapy, and other forms of healing.
That being said, there are days when you just want to eat that chocolate even though you’re full! No hidden restrictions, no hidden distress. That’s totally ok! Once you become an intuitive eater, most of the time you will respect your hunger and satiation. But not all the time! The perfect intuitive eater does not exist! But on the rare occasions that you didn’t listen to you signals, it won’t matter because your intuitive body will eventually restore balance. We all have times when we’re so busy we skip a meal, or when we over-indulge during Christmas dinner because the food is just insanely good. No need to panic. When you trust your body to lead the way, you know that these are exceptions to the rule, and your body will naturally compensate by eating more or less at the next meal - without you having to think about it at all! Studies show that intuitive eaters naturally adjust their caloric intake according to the previous meal’s calories, without even knowing it - restricted eaters cannot do this. Intuitive eaters are also able to maintain a very stable weight even when consuming a highly variable amount of calories each day, because it balances out over the long term. Remember, it’s what you eat regularly that matters, not what you eat at a few family parties! One meal does not make or break you.
This is the last but probably the most important theoretical concept in this blog. We’ve talked a lot about the physical, but we need to delve deeper into the emotional processes behind intuitive eating. Without learning more about trust and pleasure, we cannot move forward.
Every diet, every restriction, teaches you not to trust your body, not to trust food. You see yourself going from one extreme to another, losing control, feeling up and down. Your inability to achieve the goal of weight loss or weight maintenance leaves you feeling like a failure. But what has failed you is the dieting mentality and its lies, not your willpower. When you no longer listen to your body, you become more reliant on external sources to guide your eating: what’s available in front of you, levels of stress, marketing, etc. The more you are in tune with your body signals, the less vulnerable to “externally-directed” eating you become. Intuitive eating implies trust in your body, and this can be very difficult if you’ve lost it a long time ago. You may even think it’s impossible. But I’ve read about people who dieted up to the age of 60 and were finally able to reconnect with their hunger and satiety signals despite decades of mistrust. So I’m sure you can do it too.
So many people I talk to think that this method won’t work for them because they’re different, or too far gone, or too gluttonous. That’s just not true. The only people for whom Intuitive Eating doesn’t work are those who never really rekindle the trust with their body signals and never really let go of their restrictions. The ones who only give “pseudo-permission” to their body to become the leader of their eating behaviour, rather than unconditional permission. If you learn to give yourself this unconditional permission, you can learn to eat intuitively, lose weight (if you’re above your set-point) and find peace. Remember, we were all born intuitive eaters, it’s in our nature. There are no records of overweight wild animals because of all of them are intuitive eaters, as we are. They use instincts, never brains, to decide when to eat, what to eat, and how much.
Finally, we must also talk about pleasure, because food has been and always will be a hedonic activity. Pleasure is such an important part of life and eating, yet we often ignore it for the sake of weight loss and “nutrition”! Some people even feel that they don’t deserve to eat certain foods because they’re overweight. When eating is dissociated with pleasure, it becomes a chore - or even worse, a war. No peace can be found on a battleground. But satisfying your “psychological” hunger (in the sense of getting pleasure from your food) is as vital as satisfying your physical hunger. Eating carrots when you wanted chocolate will leave you feeling discontent and looking for something else. In the end, it will lead you to overeat. That’s why cravings and tastebuds are also important to listen to when you choose what you’re going to eat next. So strive to feel satisfied with what you eat, it will help prevent overeating!
On the road to becoming an intuitive eater, you will notice that every food item that you eat brings you a certain amount of pleasure that is finite, and same goes for the overall meal. Why does the first bite always taste better than the last? Let’s call it food saturation. There’s general food saturation and food-specific saturation. So every food item follows a decreasing curve, where the first bites are the best and the following bites are less and less satisfying. When you are aware of your senses and pay attention to your body signals, it’s pretty easy to tell when you’ve had enough of something (when you’ve reached food-specific saturation) and that soup or salad no longer provides any pleasure. That’s when it’s time to stop eating the food item, no matter how much is left in your plate, and move on to the next course, if you’ve not yet reached general saturation. Having variety in your plate obviously makes eating more enjoyable as there’s less of each food, so it takes longer to get tired of the general meal. This food-specific saturation phenomenon explains why we can be “full” for one food and still “hungry” for another. Contrary to what most people think, being unable to finish your main course but still having room for dessert is possible and even common. (No, it’s not just kid manipulation techniques!) Finally, it’s only when general saturation (satiation) is attained that the meal is over. You are no longer hungry for anything, and it’s time to stop eating. Again, this does not depend on what’s left in the plate, but only on your body signals. The feeling can be vague if you’ve ignored your signals for a long time, but one day it will be come very clear, as it is for intuitive eaters.
But what if “desire” comes in conflict with “satiety”? What if I still crave that chocolate even when I’m already full? It’s a complex issue. First, if you’re not yet an intuitive eater, the presence of cravings in the absence of hunger are probably residual symptoms of your restrictions. You’re still not giving yourself full permission to eat everything, you’re still hanging on to the belief that you must control what you eat, and that some unhealthy foods should be abstained from. In that case, you can’t fool your body: it will still think that calories are scarce, that it could starve tomorrow, that the food it wants might be taken away at anytime. It reacts by wanting to stock up in fear of future deprivation. Second, this could be a sign of emotional eating. Chocolate might be a comfort food - and even though your physical hunger has been quenched, your emotional needs are not fully met and you seek to appease yourself with food. But unfortunately, eating chocolate will not solve your emotional issues. It will probably even make it worse, because you will overeat and then feel ashamed of overeating, therefore increasing emotional distress. The only way out is to deal with the negative emotions that are leading you to eat without hunger in the first place, and instead turn to self-help, meditation, therapy, and other forms of healing.
That being said, there are days when you just want to eat that chocolate even though you’re full! No hidden restrictions, no hidden distress. That’s totally ok! Once you become an intuitive eater, most of the time you will respect your hunger and satiation. But not all the time! The perfect intuitive eater does not exist! But on the rare occasions that you didn’t listen to you signals, it won’t matter because your intuitive body will eventually restore balance. We all have times when we’re so busy we skip a meal, or when we over-indulge during Christmas dinner because the food is just insanely good. No need to panic. When you trust your body to lead the way, you know that these are exceptions to the rule, and your body will naturally compensate by eating more or less at the next meal - without you having to think about it at all! Studies show that intuitive eaters naturally adjust their caloric intake according to the previous meal’s calories, without even knowing it - restricted eaters cannot do this. Intuitive eaters are also able to maintain a very stable weight even when consuming a highly variable amount of calories each day, because it balances out over the long term. Remember, it’s what you eat regularly that matters, not what you eat at a few family parties! One meal does not make or break you.

Comments
Post a Comment