Do You Forbid Yourself to Eat Certain Foods?
The Myth of Fattening Foods
If you’ve been following the blog for a while, you now understand the importance of listening to your hunger and satiation signals in order for your body to maintain its set-point weight. You know that the opposite (restriction) induces binges and slower metabolism, which inevitably lead to medium-term weight cycling and long-term weight gain. You are now ready to become an intuitive eater. But, you probably still have a hard time believing that the body can do EVERYTHING by itself. Surely it needs the brain to guide it, to help choose between “fattening” and “non-fattening” foods, “healthy” and “unhealthy” foods?
First off, let’s be clear: there’s no such thing as fattening or non-fattening food. Obviously foods vary in calorie density (calorie content per volume or weight). Chocolate has more calories per gram than carrots. BUT eating a piece of chocolate is less fattening than eating a kilogram of carrots! So it’s the total amount of calories that you eat versus spend which will determine your net weight gain or loss, not the food type by itself. No one category of food ever caused anyone to become fat. And if you continue to label foods as good or bad, it will only prevent you from ever becoming an intuitive eater.
One way in which blacklisting foods is counterproductive is the fact that your attempts to replace these foods will always fail - everything else you will eat to mask the craving will never be as satisfying. If you feel like chocolate but instead you eat carrots, you will not satisfy your chocolate craving and will be left with a sensation of emptiness. Your body, discontent, will seek out more. It will eat and eat and eat all the “allowed” foods, in search of the contentment which only the “forbidden” food can provide. In the end, you will definitely overeat. How many times, when craving chocolate, have you eaten a few carrots, felt unsatisfied, then proceeded to eat nuts, and then a fruit... and maybe ended up eating that darn chocolate anyway! What if you had just eaten the piece of chocolate like you wanted to? You’d have ingested less total calories AND felt more content.
This a common problem with non-intuitive eaters. They simply cannot understand how, while restricting so much, while eating only salads and low-calorie foods, they still do not manage to lose any weight! They do not realise that, having given themselves unconditional permission to eat “healthy” foods but without listening to their signals, they consistently overeat them without even noticing, thinking that these allowed foods aren’t fattening anyway. Yes, believe it or not, you can get fat with salads if you ingest more total calories than you spend. (And the opposite is also true: you can stay slim while eating chocolate.) The overeating of allowed foods usually happens in specific circumstances: 1. trying to silence the craving for a forbidden food, 2. trying to eat according to dieting rules or beliefs (such as breakfast is mandatory), 3. trying to eat preventively to appease binge anxiety (e.g. snacking before going to a restaurant or a Christmas dinner, as a way to resist tempting foods). No matter what the reason may be, eating any food in the absence of hunger or beyond satiation inevitably leads to weight gain, whether it’s chocolate or carrots. The distinction between good and bad foods is irrelevant to weight.
The problem is, you can easily eat just one carrot but you cannot eat just one piece of chocolate (or chips or whatever blacklisted “fattening” food)! The very act of forbidding certain foods changed something in your psyche and in the relationship you have with these foods - they become precious, tantalizing, threatening. You may even become obsessed with them and/or crave them all the time. Then when you eventually come across them, your body identifies them as super rare food items and knows that this may be the last opportunity it will ever get to eat them... We have already seen that this is what leads to binges. It’s also important to recognise the emotions that occur during and after the compulsive behaviours: guilt and shame. These deeply negative feelings, instead of helping you achieve your goals, are completely counterproductive and are actually powerful drivers of compulsion. The labelling of “bad” foods and the attempts to shun them means there can never be peace in their presence. The out-of-control, desperate, deprived way in which we eat blacklisted foods does NOT stem from lack of willpower, but is biology and emotion driven. This is how the body and the mind works. When you stop restricting yourself, not only do you stop giving your body incentive to hoard or binge, you eliminate the feelings of guilt and shame that have permeated your relationship with certain types of food - or even food in general. You start to free yourself of the shackles of emotional eating and make your way towards intuitive eating, where needs (communicated through bodily signals) become the main driving forces of feeding behaviours.
If you’ve been following the blog for a while, you now understand the importance of listening to your hunger and satiation signals in order for your body to maintain its set-point weight. You know that the opposite (restriction) induces binges and slower metabolism, which inevitably lead to medium-term weight cycling and long-term weight gain. You are now ready to become an intuitive eater. But, you probably still have a hard time believing that the body can do EVERYTHING by itself. Surely it needs the brain to guide it, to help choose between “fattening” and “non-fattening” foods, “healthy” and “unhealthy” foods?
First off, let’s be clear: there’s no such thing as fattening or non-fattening food. Obviously foods vary in calorie density (calorie content per volume or weight). Chocolate has more calories per gram than carrots. BUT eating a piece of chocolate is less fattening than eating a kilogram of carrots! So it’s the total amount of calories that you eat versus spend which will determine your net weight gain or loss, not the food type by itself. No one category of food ever caused anyone to become fat. And if you continue to label foods as good or bad, it will only prevent you from ever becoming an intuitive eater.
One way in which blacklisting foods is counterproductive is the fact that your attempts to replace these foods will always fail - everything else you will eat to mask the craving will never be as satisfying. If you feel like chocolate but instead you eat carrots, you will not satisfy your chocolate craving and will be left with a sensation of emptiness. Your body, discontent, will seek out more. It will eat and eat and eat all the “allowed” foods, in search of the contentment which only the “forbidden” food can provide. In the end, you will definitely overeat. How many times, when craving chocolate, have you eaten a few carrots, felt unsatisfied, then proceeded to eat nuts, and then a fruit... and maybe ended up eating that darn chocolate anyway! What if you had just eaten the piece of chocolate like you wanted to? You’d have ingested less total calories AND felt more content.
This a common problem with non-intuitive eaters. They simply cannot understand how, while restricting so much, while eating only salads and low-calorie foods, they still do not manage to lose any weight! They do not realise that, having given themselves unconditional permission to eat “healthy” foods but without listening to their signals, they consistently overeat them without even noticing, thinking that these allowed foods aren’t fattening anyway. Yes, believe it or not, you can get fat with salads if you ingest more total calories than you spend. (And the opposite is also true: you can stay slim while eating chocolate.) The overeating of allowed foods usually happens in specific circumstances: 1. trying to silence the craving for a forbidden food, 2. trying to eat according to dieting rules or beliefs (such as breakfast is mandatory), 3. trying to eat preventively to appease binge anxiety (e.g. snacking before going to a restaurant or a Christmas dinner, as a way to resist tempting foods). No matter what the reason may be, eating any food in the absence of hunger or beyond satiation inevitably leads to weight gain, whether it’s chocolate or carrots. The distinction between good and bad foods is irrelevant to weight.The problem is, you can easily eat just one carrot but you cannot eat just one piece of chocolate (or chips or whatever blacklisted “fattening” food)! The very act of forbidding certain foods changed something in your psyche and in the relationship you have with these foods - they become precious, tantalizing, threatening. You may even become obsessed with them and/or crave them all the time. Then when you eventually come across them, your body identifies them as super rare food items and knows that this may be the last opportunity it will ever get to eat them... We have already seen that this is what leads to binges. It’s also important to recognise the emotions that occur during and after the compulsive behaviours: guilt and shame. These deeply negative feelings, instead of helping you achieve your goals, are completely counterproductive and are actually powerful drivers of compulsion. The labelling of “bad” foods and the attempts to shun them means there can never be peace in their presence. The out-of-control, desperate, deprived way in which we eat blacklisted foods does NOT stem from lack of willpower, but is biology and emotion driven. This is how the body and the mind works. When you stop restricting yourself, not only do you stop giving your body incentive to hoard or binge, you eliminate the feelings of guilt and shame that have permeated your relationship with certain types of food - or even food in general. You start to free yourself of the shackles of emotional eating and make your way towards intuitive eating, where needs (communicated through bodily signals) become the main driving forces of feeding behaviours.

Comments
Post a Comment