Posts

Mon cheminement vers l'alimentation intuitive

Image
De la minceur de l'enfance au trouble alimentaire J'aimerais te partager mon histoire. Toi, qui lutte contre ton poids, la nourriture, l'exercice. Toi qui as du mal à t'accepter. Je comprends ton désarroi et je pense pouvoir t'aider. Ça fait des années que j'y réfléchis, que je veux mettre en mots mes expériences. Mais j'hésitais. Par honte, par timidité, mais aussi par excès de perfectionnisme. Je voulais à tout prix trouver le moyen parfait, celui qui aurait le plus d'impact sur le plus grand nombre de personnes. Je ne suis pas certaine de l'avoir trouvé, mais j'ai décidé d'aller de l'avant quand même, inspirée et touchée par toutes les personnes que j'ai rencontrées sur mon chemin, surtout des femmes mais de plus en plus d'hommes, qui souffrent en silence. J'ai toujours été une enfant mince qui pouvait manger ce qu'elle voulait, quand elle voulait. En grandissant, j'avais des complexes physiques comme tout le monde,...

Is this blog for me?

Image
Do you have food/weight issues? To answer this, ask yourself these questions: Have you ever dieted? Do you ignore your hunger? Do you have a love-hate relationship with food? Do you feel guilt or shame for eating certain foods? Do you eat beyond fullness? Are there foods you forbid yourself to eat or buy? Do you eat out of stress, boredom, sadness, nervousness? Are you unsatisfied with your body weight? Do you hate looking at yourself in the mirror or in pictures? Do you exercise to “burn off calories”? Are you a “health freak” that chooses carefully every food item? Are you afraid of restaurants and parties because of the risk of overeating? Do you eat a lot of “good” foods to avoid cravings for “bad” foods? Have you ever promised yourself over and over that you will have more control next time, to eat less and to resist temptations? If you have answered YES to some of the above, you might have food/weight issues or even an Eating Disorder Not Otherwise Specified (EDNOS) or Disordered...

Fundamental Principles

Image
How the Body Works In the same way that you have a preset body temperature, you also have a predetermined weight and your body will do everything in its power to maintain that weight. You can call it your “healthy”, “natural” or “genetic” weight. I will use the term set-point. In order to maintain its set-point weight, your body communicates with you through signals of hunger and satiation (indicating the amount of food you need to eat), as well as cravings (indicating the types of food you need to eat). Restriction inevitably leads to excess. If you do not satisfy your hunger, you will feel intense urges to eat compulsively and excessively (i.e. binges). Every time you restrict yourself, you are no longer listening to your body’s signals aka eating instructions (so eventually it stops talking to you properly) and simultaneously, you are sending a dangerous message to your body that food supply is low (so it starts going into starvation mode). When your body is in starvation mode, it w...

Homeostasis

Image
Finding Balance During undergrad, I started out with a major in Physiology and later switched to Biomedical Sciences. One of the first principles we learned in physiology classes was HOMEOSTASIS, defined by dictionary.com as “The tendency of the body to seek and maintain a condition of balance or equilibrium within its internal environment, even when faced with external changes.” What this means is, you have a predetermined biological “set point” (a state of equilibrium) for most physiological functions, and in the presence of outside disruptions your body will always try to bring you back to this set-point. For example, through complex mechanisms, your body will maintain your internal temperature at around 37°C despite external variations in temperature. When the environment gets too hot, your body sweats to cool down; when it gets too cold, your body shivers to generate some heat. Similarly, your blood sodium levels always stay between 135 and 145 mmol/L no matter how much water or s...

Channels of Communication

Image
Your Body ’ s Talking, Are You Listening? As mentioned previously, at any given moment in all living organisms, there’s complex communication going on between the cells and organs of the body, relaying important messages for survival. These signals occur well beyond conscious control and do not depend on our awareness to function. They only enter our consciousness when there is the need to change our behaviour to fulfill a basic need, such as eating. The body is acutely aware of how much food and calories and macronutrients are available and how much more is needed. It will communicate this information to us through signals of hunger (time to eat) and satiation (time to stop eating). More subtly, it can also tell us that we’re low on a specific kind of nutrient by inducing cravings for certain types of foods. However, because the human brain is a powerful machine of central control, it can of course override essential bodily signals and functions. This can be extremely useful (e.g. ...

Restriction Always Leads to Excess

Image
The Origin of Binges Previously, we have seen what happens in the mind and body of the intuitive eater who maintains a homeostatic weight by listening carefully to their signals of hunger and satiation. So what happens in the body of the non-intuitive eater? The vast majority of non-intuitive eaters are in a state of chronic restriction. This does not mean that they are underweight or starving - only that their brain is constantly attempting to override their body. They are never fully relaxed around meals. Most experts call this state cognitive restriction . As such, non-intuitive eaters have one goal - weight loss - and one archenemy - weight gain. Anything that could make them overeat, whether it’s their own hunger, the presence of tempting foods or social contexts that promote eating (e.g. restaurants, parties), is seen as a threat. In short, they are at constant war with food and themselves. But they’ve devised clever strategies. Non-intuitive eaters have, not always consciously, ...

Further Away from Homeostasis

Image
Other Unnatural Consequences of Restriction As we have seen, every time you choose to ignore your hunger, i.e. not feed your body when it requires energy and demands food, you are telling your body there is a famine. All forms of diets do this, even the “light” ones, even the ones that promise you won’t go hungry or claim that you can eat what you want. Do not be fooled: in every diet, there’s always obvious or hidden restrictions. We have seen that restriction leads to binges (eating uncontrollably and excessively) as a compensatory response to the periods of restriction. Binges are nothing but an attempt to break the famine, a strategy we can label as “desperately increasing caloric intake”. Another response to intense or prolonged restriction is to save energy at all costs - it’s a “desperately decreasing caloric expenditure” kind of strategy. Let’s see how it works. When the body’s energy requirements are not met through adequate food intake (i.e. hunger signals are not fo...

Do You Forbid Yourself to Eat Certain Foods?

Image
The Myth of Fattening Foods If you’ve been following the blog for a while, you now understand the importance of listening to your hunger and satiation signals in order for your body to maintain its set-point weight. You know that the opposite (restriction) induces binges and slower metabolism, which inevitably lead to medium-term weight cycling and long-term weight gain. You are now ready to become an intuitive eater. But, you probably still have a hard time believing that the body can do EVERYTHING by itself. Surely it needs the brain to guide it, to help choose between “fattening” and “non-fattening” foods, “healthy” and “unhealthy” foods? First off, let’s be clear: there’s no such thing as fattening or non-fattening food. Obviously foods vary in calorie density (calorie content per volume or weight). Chocolate has more calories per gram than carrots. BUT eating a piece of chocolate is less fattening than eating a kilogram of carrots! So it’s the total amount of calories that you eat...

The Tricky Signal: Satiation

Image
Please Do Not Finish Your Plate We have talked a lot about respecting your hunger and not ever letting yourself starve. But what about that other signal that tells you when to stop eating? For many people, hunger signals are relatively easy to recognise while satiety is a major struggle. Maybe, like me, you’ve been raised with parents who told you to always finish your plate, parents who were allergic to food waste and ranted about poor children not having enough to eat. Or maybe you’ve always thought of yourself as “gluttonous”, a “food lover” that just can’t stop eating. For some, this behaviour takes place at almost every meal, for others it only occurs with certain foods. Either way, eating often feels out of control, and guilt and shame are frequent outcomes. We’ve seen that restricting and blacklisting food types were two of the main causes, but let’s also talk about how other mislead beliefs can lead to counterproductive and harmful eating behaviours. Where did the ...

So What's Wrong with Trying to Be Healthy?

Image
Intuitive Eating Before Healthy Eating When I said in a previous post that I wanted you to be able to eat cookies and chips as you please, I’m sure many of you immediately thought “but, what about health?”. Isn’t it ok to want to avoid cookies and chips because they are unhealthy? So let’s talk about that. I am, after all, a doctor, and obviously concerned with health. While modern society is incredibly unhealthy in so many ways, it is also health crazy in other ways, which is just as harmful. Excessive preoccupation with healthy eating has become so widespread that a new term was coined in 1997 to describe the phenomenon - orthorexia . The idea came from U.S. doctor Steven Bratman who suggested, according to Wikipedia, “that some people’s dietary restrictions intended to promote health may paradoxically lead to unhealthy consequences, such as social isolation, anxiety, loss of ability to eat in a natural, intuitive manner , reduced interest in the full range of other healthy human act...

Forget the Gym!

Image
Why Exercise is Not a Weight Loss Solution Of course exercise is great for physical and mental health. But no matter what the fitness industry tries to sell, it is NOT a sustainable weight loss method, according to the best scientific evidence. As explained before, most of the calories you spend are used up by your metabolism. Only a small amount is actually spent during exercise (unless you’re a high-level athlete). All the calories you think you burnt at the gym or on that jog are easily undone by just one meal where you overeat. As you now know, non-intuitive eating means your feeding behaviour does not match your caloric needs, and therefore frequent out-of-control eating will erase or even counteract the effects of increased caloric expenditure achieved through physical activity. Here’s a great video that explains the concept. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eXTiiz99p9o Since food intake has the most influence on weight, you must solve your food issues if you ever hope to achieve ...

Trust and Pleasure

Image
Eating is Intrinsically Emotional This is the last but probably the most important theoretical concept in this blog. We’ve talked a lot about the physical, but we need to delve deeper into the emotional processes behind intuitive eating. Without learning more about trust and pleasure, we cannot move forward. Every diet, every restriction, teaches you not to trust your body, not to trust food. You see yourself going from one extreme to another, losing control, feeling up and down. Your inability to achieve the goal of weight loss or weight maintenance leaves you feeling like a failure. But what has failed you is the dieting mentality and its lies, not your willpower. When you no longer listen to your body, you become more reliant on external sources to guide your eating: what’s available in front of you, levels of stress, marketing, etc. The more you are in tune with your body signals, the less vulnerable to “externally-directed” eating you become. Intuitive eating implies ...

The End and the Beginning

A Summary of Key Concepts 1. Diets don’t work. Commit right now to never again go on a diet or a meal plan (or anything that vaguely resembles either). No matter how much weight your friend lost with so-and-so method, no matter how sensible that new diet seems, no matter how many health professionals recommended that “healthy eating” program. You now know that there are only two possible outcomes to restriction: neverending rollercoaster rides with your weight, with harmful consequences on your health and inevitable weight gain in the long run OR a constant state of watchfulness and inhibition without the possibility of relaxing around a meal and fully enjoying what you crave. Remember that diets will not help you achieve your ultimate goals, the most important of which are happiness and satisfaction. Have you just heard about a new way of eating that claims to be non-restrictive? Apparently you are allowed to eat what you want, even bad foods! Seems too good to be true, righ...

Inspirational Quotes

Just reading this blog might not be enough for you. I understand! If you need help, I highly recommend either seeing a nutritionist who specialises in intuitive eating (this is a must! I’ve known nutritionists who’ve done more harm than good to people, like inducing or worsening eating disorders!), and/or reading one or several of the books below. Here are some of my favourite quotes. Intuitive Eating By Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch Dieting is a form of short-term starvation The mere contemplation of going on a diet brings on urges and cravings for “sinful” foods and “fatty favorites”… Eating is often experienced at such intensity that it feels uncontrollable, a desperate act. You can’t fight biology. When the body is starving, it needs to be nourished. When underfed, you will obsess about food. Unconscious dieting usually occurs in the form of meticulous eating habits. There can be a fine line between eating for health and dieting. Once you reach the moment of excessive hunger, all ...