Channels of Communication
Your Body’s Talking, Are You Listening?
As mentioned previously, at any given moment in all living organisms, there’s complex communication going on between the cells and organs of the body, relaying important messages for survival. These signals occur well beyond conscious control and do not depend on our awareness to function. They only enter our consciousness when there is the need to change our behaviour to fulfill a basic need, such as eating.
The body is acutely aware of how much food and calories and macronutrients are available and how much more is needed. It will communicate this information to us through signals of hunger (time to eat) and satiation (time to stop eating). More subtly, it can also tell us that we’re low on a specific kind of nutrient by inducing cravings for certain types of foods. However, because the human brain is a powerful machine of central control, it can of course override essential bodily signals and functions. This can be extremely useful (e.g. stopping us from peeing our pants in public) or extremely dangerous (e.g. stopping us from eating to the point of starvation, like in anorexia).
So how do intuitive eaters maintain a stable weight over a long term period? The rule is quite simple: calories in, calories out. If you always eat as much calories as you spend, there will never be any weight gain. All throughout history, humans have known exactly how to do this simply by following their inner signals. Overweight and obesity are new phenomena that arose when the brain started to take over the body’s role. The result is disastrous: as clever as the brain is, it can only keep track of conscious processes, not unconscious ones such as the complex feedback loops involved in metabolism and weight maintenance. Our body is still the world’s most perfect and exact calorie counter.
So how does it work? Basal metabolism, the energy required to keep vital functions going including muscle contraction, breathing and blood flow, uses up most of our energy. And contrary to popular belief, exercise accounts for very little of total energy expenditure, except for very high level athletes. When calories have been spent and energy is low, a web of internal messages kick in and hormones such as ghrelin are secreted to promote feeding behaviour, which in turn is interpreted by the intuitive eater as “I’m hungry”. It is a state of slight discomfort, at first only an itch, a vague sense of emptiness. The only way to calm and neutralise the signal is to eat. If you ignore the message however, it will grow stronger and more insisting. If left unattended, hunger turns to famishment.
I used to be afraid of hunger - it meant the risk of overeating. Hunger felt like a wild, out of control beast that could crush all my food resolutions and shatter any dreams of weight loss. And it’s because it was! Restricting (ignoring my hunger and cravings) meant they never appeared in a discrete and modest form, but always intense and desperate. Now I cherish hunger, I know it simply means I’ve spent my available energy and deserve a good meal to replenish my stocks. Feeling hungry means my body is working properly, and I’m able to read its signals accurately. As I’ve learned to respect and honour these signals, the body’s tyrannical urgings have turned into soft nudgings. Instead of a monster, I now see hunger as my little shoulder angel, guiding me towards the right eating behaviour.
Intuitive eaters who listen to their hunger do not fear excess because there’s always that other signal, satiation, to stop them when they’ve eaten enough. Once enough calories have been ingested and energy levels are replenished, the body secretes a new set of hormones such as leptin that seek to interrupt feeding behaviour. This is interpreted by the intuitive eater as “I’m full”. The body no longer needs any food and tells us so by creating a feeling of satisfaction and completeness, a return to comfort, a relief to the itch created by hunger. This is the state of satiation. If disregarded, overeating (eating past the point of satiation) leads to feeling stuffed, bursting, and even nauseous. This is where weight gain happens.
Hunger is our green light for eating. Satiation is the red light. Together, they give us the precise boundaries between energy depletion and energy restoration, they keep our bodies at set-point weight and homeostasis. The mechanisms are super precise. If these two signals are fully respected, weight can be maintained stable for a lifetime. As kids, most of us were intuitive eaters and we did all of this effortlessly. We didn’t have to think much about what to eat, when and how much. But as adults, we un-learned our instincts and bodily signals, and turned to so-called “knowledge” and “common sense” to direct our feeding behaviours.
This misplaced wisdom has done us wrong, very wrong. We have lost connection with our bodies and attempted to replace its natural signals with artificial norms. Whether we are following unconscious eating rules or strict dieting rules, we are ignoring our hunger and satiation signals and setting ourselves up for trouble. Food labels, apps and calculators can NEVER accurately estimate the amount of calories we ingest and the amount we spend - only our own bodies can do that. Relying on external cues to dictate how we eat means we will always be off, by a small or large margin, and thus our weight will fluctuate according to our miscalculations and the disastrous consequences of repressed hunger and satiation. The next post will detail the phenomena behind dieting (restriction) and binges (excess), and how one inevitably creates the other.
As mentioned previously, at any given moment in all living organisms, there’s complex communication going on between the cells and organs of the body, relaying important messages for survival. These signals occur well beyond conscious control and do not depend on our awareness to function. They only enter our consciousness when there is the need to change our behaviour to fulfill a basic need, such as eating.
The body is acutely aware of how much food and calories and macronutrients are available and how much more is needed. It will communicate this information to us through signals of hunger (time to eat) and satiation (time to stop eating). More subtly, it can also tell us that we’re low on a specific kind of nutrient by inducing cravings for certain types of foods. However, because the human brain is a powerful machine of central control, it can of course override essential bodily signals and functions. This can be extremely useful (e.g. stopping us from peeing our pants in public) or extremely dangerous (e.g. stopping us from eating to the point of starvation, like in anorexia).
So how do intuitive eaters maintain a stable weight over a long term period? The rule is quite simple: calories in, calories out. If you always eat as much calories as you spend, there will never be any weight gain. All throughout history, humans have known exactly how to do this simply by following their inner signals. Overweight and obesity are new phenomena that arose when the brain started to take over the body’s role. The result is disastrous: as clever as the brain is, it can only keep track of conscious processes, not unconscious ones such as the complex feedback loops involved in metabolism and weight maintenance. Our body is still the world’s most perfect and exact calorie counter.
So how does it work? Basal metabolism, the energy required to keep vital functions going including muscle contraction, breathing and blood flow, uses up most of our energy. And contrary to popular belief, exercise accounts for very little of total energy expenditure, except for very high level athletes. When calories have been spent and energy is low, a web of internal messages kick in and hormones such as ghrelin are secreted to promote feeding behaviour, which in turn is interpreted by the intuitive eater as “I’m hungry”. It is a state of slight discomfort, at first only an itch, a vague sense of emptiness. The only way to calm and neutralise the signal is to eat. If you ignore the message however, it will grow stronger and more insisting. If left unattended, hunger turns to famishment.
I used to be afraid of hunger - it meant the risk of overeating. Hunger felt like a wild, out of control beast that could crush all my food resolutions and shatter any dreams of weight loss. And it’s because it was! Restricting (ignoring my hunger and cravings) meant they never appeared in a discrete and modest form, but always intense and desperate. Now I cherish hunger, I know it simply means I’ve spent my available energy and deserve a good meal to replenish my stocks. Feeling hungry means my body is working properly, and I’m able to read its signals accurately. As I’ve learned to respect and honour these signals, the body’s tyrannical urgings have turned into soft nudgings. Instead of a monster, I now see hunger as my little shoulder angel, guiding me towards the right eating behaviour.
Intuitive eaters who listen to their hunger do not fear excess because there’s always that other signal, satiation, to stop them when they’ve eaten enough. Once enough calories have been ingested and energy levels are replenished, the body secretes a new set of hormones such as leptin that seek to interrupt feeding behaviour. This is interpreted by the intuitive eater as “I’m full”. The body no longer needs any food and tells us so by creating a feeling of satisfaction and completeness, a return to comfort, a relief to the itch created by hunger. This is the state of satiation. If disregarded, overeating (eating past the point of satiation) leads to feeling stuffed, bursting, and even nauseous. This is where weight gain happens.
Hunger is our green light for eating. Satiation is the red light. Together, they give us the precise boundaries between energy depletion and energy restoration, they keep our bodies at set-point weight and homeostasis. The mechanisms are super precise. If these two signals are fully respected, weight can be maintained stable for a lifetime. As kids, most of us were intuitive eaters and we did all of this effortlessly. We didn’t have to think much about what to eat, when and how much. But as adults, we un-learned our instincts and bodily signals, and turned to so-called “knowledge” and “common sense” to direct our feeding behaviours.
This misplaced wisdom has done us wrong, very wrong. We have lost connection with our bodies and attempted to replace its natural signals with artificial norms. Whether we are following unconscious eating rules or strict dieting rules, we are ignoring our hunger and satiation signals and setting ourselves up for trouble. Food labels, apps and calculators can NEVER accurately estimate the amount of calories we ingest and the amount we spend - only our own bodies can do that. Relying on external cues to dictate how we eat means we will always be off, by a small or large margin, and thus our weight will fluctuate according to our miscalculations and the disastrous consequences of repressed hunger and satiation. The next post will detail the phenomena behind dieting (restriction) and binges (excess), and how one inevitably creates the other.
Comments
Post a Comment